The Harvard Law Record

Independent at Harvard Law School since 1946

Opinion

‘I Want to Use My Privilege to Serve the Greater Good’: HLS Students on Forgoing Big Law

Testimonials from HLS students not pursuing Big Law explain why they are choosing a different path — and what they want undecided classmates to know.

Photo: The Harvard Law Record.

Editor’s Note: Since 2022, The Harvard Law Record has published testimonials from students who signed the You Are Not Alone campaign, which invites HLS students forgoing Big Law to add their names to a public list. The campaign is coordinated by the Law & Social Change Fellows.

This year, The Record is publishing a selection of those testimonials as a standalone piece. The full set of testimonials and the list of signatories (165 students as of Nov. 16) are available here.

For context, Harvard Law School’s ABA employment summary for the Class of 2025 reports the following outcomes for its 594 employed graduates:

•Law firms: 64% (54% at firms of more than 500 attorneys)

•Judicial clerkships: 20% (17% federal)

•Public interest: 10%

•Business & industry: 3%

•Government: 3%

•Education: 1%

The summary does not show how many clerks later join firms.

Testimonials respond to three questions posed by the campaign, reflect only the views of their authors, and have been lightly edited for clarity. The Record verified the identities of all contributors; some asked that their names be withheld.

Why are you choosing not to pursue a career in Big Law? 

Zerxes Bhadha, JD ’27: I came to law school because I wanted to help create a world in which people are free to live happy, fulfilling lives. Big Law firms and their work are directly opposed to creating the type of world I want to live in, and I refuse to let my labor, power, and privilege prop up state and corporate violence that harms the communities and people I care most about. More importantly, I find joy in being in community with good people doing good work, and I look forward to carrying that joy with me for my entire career.

Anonymous, JD ’29: I did not come to Harvard Law School, with all of its resources and power, to waste my time being a tiny cog in a massive machine defending corporations doing immense harm to my community. 

Silas Olsen, JD ’28: I chose not to pursue a Big Law career because I’d rather be middle class and fight against injustice than become rich and famous by stepping on the necks of the underserved.

Anonymous, JD ’29: I previously worked in Big Law and believed it was a place where really important pro bono work could happen. But no amount of pro bono work that Big Law firms do can mitigate the harm that they cause. 

Ranen Miao, JD ’29: I believe it’s a privilege to get a Harvard Law degree, and I hope to use my education to serve those without a voice or representation in the legal system. I am choosing not to pursue Big Law because I believe big corporations already have enough lawyers and lobbyists to serve their interests, and we need more people fighting in court for the little guy. My commitment to public service is rooted in the communities I come from, and I hope to spend my time in law school exploring the many ways I can leverage my law degree to serve low-income people, communities of color, queer and trans people, women, immigrants, our environment, consumers, and the public good. 

Mia Stone-Molloy, JD ’27: How you spend your days is how you spend your life. I want to spend mine working for the movements that give me hope, with enough free time to spend with the people and hobbies that give me joy.

Hannah Witkin, JD ’29: I came to law school to serve people, not profits. Being at HLS is an immense privilege and carries with it an obligation to be a force for justice. I sleep great knowing I will do meaningful work, live comfortably, and have time to be present for my community and the people I love. 

Anonymous, JD ’28: Why would I work 80-plus hours a week in a cold, liminal office defending random corporations when I could have work-life balance, make a decent living, work in my field of interest, and make the world a better place? The choice seems very simple.

Amber Magnuson, JD ’27: I can’t justify spending 21 years in school just to help corporations hold onto their money. 

Greta Maras, JD ’27: No amount of money is worth defending tobacco companies, gas companies, and the other various serial abusers of power that sap people’s health, money, and livelihoods. A Harvard Law degree is an immense privilege, and I want to pay that forward with a career that serves the public interest. 

Anonymous, JD ’28: I entered law school to advocate for women’s rights. I do not buy the Big Law propaganda that I can do what I’m passionate about with my pro bono hours – women’s liberation is not a part-time activity. 

Rachel Hatfield, JD ’29: I came to law school to live out my vocation as a Christian to love my neighbor and the least of these! I can’t think of a better use of my HLS education than to help support Black, Brown, and low-income communities facing state violence. Education is a privilege and a gift from God, and I owe it back to Him for His purposes of justice for the marginalized and oppressed. 

Anonymous, JD ’28: I entered 1L with an open mind about career options. After attending many lunch/firm events, I gathered enough information to know that a career in Big Law did not align with my personal values. Specifically, I did not feel there was enough work currently in my interest area at the large firms, and I did not feel the lifestyle would allow me to be a present partner, eventual parent, and community member. I also learned that LIPP [HLS’s Low Income Protection Plan] would allow me to pursue careers more closely aligned with my mission while making my loans manageable.

Rose Wagner, JD ’29: I came to law school to challenge and change systems, not enable them.

Savannah Freitas, JD ’28: I have the privilege of being at a university with SPIF [Summer Public Interest Funding], LIPP, loan repayment assistance for PSLF [Public Service Loan Forgiveness] enrollees, and many other offerings that greatly reduce the strain of student loans. Anyone who meaningfully looks into these programs will realize that this support means that there is no reason to let loans be the reason you don’t choose public interest. As someone who was going to do PI anyway, I am so glad to have these options AND amazing peers who have taken the time to explain them to me. These have only affirmed my choice of a career that I actually care about. 

Charlotte Allessio Manier, JD ’29: If I’m not helping my community, there’s no reason for me to be a lawyer. 

Jinmook Kang, JD ’29: I think we can all dream bigger than Big Law. 

What have you learned from the experience of choosing not to do Big Law recruitment?

Kayleigh Hasson, JD ’27: You will be well supported, both by your public interest peers and by OPIA [HLS’s Office of Public Interest Advising], throughout the public interest job search! Also, there are some 2L summer jobs in public interest at organizations that will hire you post-grad (e.g., public defense). 

Anonymous, JD ’28: Skipping EIP [the Early Interview Program] can be scary, especially when your peers are getting flown out for Big Law offers. But you will find an internship, and you will feel much more fulfilled in your work amongst the incredibly warm and kind PI community. If you’re on the fence, talk to 2Ls and 3Ls for advice!

Sasha Matsuki, JD ’28: There is always another option, and there are always people like you. You don’t have to cave to the pressure.

Hannah Witkin, JD ’29: There are so many more of us than you think! 

Isabella Marrin, JD ’28: One of the most meaningful things I’ve learned is just how powerful the public interest community is. I’ve found an incredibly supportive, mighty, and deeply committed community of people who believe in each other and in the work, and who remind me every day why this is the kind of career I want to build.

Aastha Sinha, JD ’28: I’ve learned that it’s rewarding to choose the path that’s right for you, which may not be the path that most of your peers take. 

Shanai Watson, JD ’29: Given that the public interest (PI) community at HLS is much smaller than the Big Law community, it has been really easy for me to find my people. The Public Interest Law Collective (PILC), Public Interest Law Student Association (PILSA), and Office of Public Interest Advising (OPIA) make it so apparent they want us to succeed in our goals despite any challenges that arise from pursuing careers that are less lucrative. Even student affinity organizations, such as the Harvard Black Law Students Association, have committees centered on supporting public interest students through mentorship and sponsoring different employment opportunities. The guidance and advice I’ve been able to gain from the PI community at HLS, particularly through the lens of being a first-generation student, has been so inspiring, and I have never felt like I was making the wrong choice to remain dedicated to public interest.

If you quit or rejected all offers, what was the deciding factor for not doing Big Law? 

Urooba Abid, JD ’28: I turned down my Big Law offers because being at HLS already gives me a safety net. This degree is a privilege and I want to use my privilege to serve the greater good.